Study Suggests Milk Doesn’t Strengthen Your Bones

By , Category : Food and Nutrition

Disclaimer: Results are not guaranteed*** and may vary from person to person***.

Milk and Bone HealthIf you told me five years ago that milk and dairy wouldn’t be part of my diet, I’d probably call you crazy.

Dairy was in all my favorite foods, from pizza to grilled cheese. At that time, I likely would’ve said, “You’re crazy right? Why would I give up such masterpieces? Especially when milk and dairy products strengthen bones, right?”

But that’s changed. Now I avoid milk and dairy because of food sensitivities. I also avoid most processed foods, and milk is typically loaded with antibiotics, growth hormones, and fortified ingredients.

And while society has been trained to believe that we need milk for strong bones and overall health, a new study suggests milk may not be linked to good bone health. In fact, in addition to not strengthening your bones, milk may also decrease your life expectancy.

I’d be shocked if I heard that, too, and maybe even a little angry or confused. But before your thoughts get too carried away, let me explain.

Milk Harms Your Health, Study Says

It is recommended that adults consume three cups of milk or dairy (750 milliliters) every day. That may seem like a lot initially, but most people—you perhaps included—eat a lot more than that. After all, dairy and milk are everywhere you turn, from ice cream to cheese and from butter to sauces. Many people begin the day with milk in their cereal or cream in their coffee or tea. They may also end the day with a tall glass of milk with dinner.

Well, as it turns out, Uppsala University researchers in Sweden recently found that high milk consumption in women may produce greater bone fractures. They also found an association with higher mortality rates in women and men and dairy consumption. The diets of 61,433 women were observed between 1987 and 1990, as well as 45,339 men in 1997. All participants completed questionnaires that revealed their dairy consumption, including cheese, yogurt, and milk.

The women were monitored for 20 years after the initial questionnaire. Of these women, 17,252 experienced a bone fracture, 4,259 experienced a hip fracture, and 15,541 passed away during this time. The researchers determined that the women who consumed three glasses of milk or more daily doubled their risk of death by the conclusion of the study.

Among male participants, there were 10,112 fatalities and only 5,066 fractures 11 years after the questionnaire. The study’s authors suggest that a simple sugar in milk, called galactose, may cause inflammation, which is what lead to the bone fractures.

Alternatives to Your Trusted Cow’s Milk

The study’s authors noted other factors could have affected the results, such as a person’s weight or alcohol consumption. The scientific community may not be giving up on milk just yet; however, it may be a good idea to consider the alternatives to milk.

Goat’s Milk and Sheep’s Milk

Goat’s milk or sheep’s milk are good alternative options to cow’s milk. They contain greater amounts of calcium compared to cow’s milk along with other nutrients. You may be able to find goat’s or sheep’s milk in your grocery store’s organic section or in your local health food store.

Almond Milk

Almond milk is your second alternative option to cow’s milk. Conveniently, almond milk has grown in popularity lately and is now available in most major grocery stores. It is best to choose almond milk without carrageenan; this is because carrageenan may contain monosodium glutamate, which is known to cause digestive issues.

Better yet, you can learn to make your own almond milk. I combine a cup of almonds, a desired sweetener, and four cups of water in a blender for two minutes. Strain the mixture through cheesecloth into a bowl or pitcher and refrigerate for three days.

Also ReadCamel’s Milk the Newest Superfood?

The Milk for Calcium Myth Busted: Top Alternative Calcium Sources

“If I cut out milk and dairy, then where do I get my calcium from?”

That is by far the most frequently asked question regarding the possibility of ending your milk habit. But this is a concern that’s far too easy to squash. When it comes to calcium, milk and dairy products aren’t your only source. In fact, one cup of two-percent milk (246 grams) contains just 295 milligrams (mg) of calcium; in comparison, a cup of almonds contains 376 mg of calcium.

Don’t forget about your leafy greens, too. These vegetables can also be a really good source of calcium, as you can see in the following chart:

Food Calcium per cup
Spinach 244.8 mg
Collard greens 226.1 mg
Dandelion greens 187.0 mg
Turnip greens 184.0 mg
Watercress 151.0 mg
Mustard greens 138.0 mg
Swiss chard 101.5 mg
Kale 93.6 mg

Finally, broccoli (130 mg of calcium per cup), Brazil nuts (186 mg of calcium per cup), and a quarter cup of sesame seeds (351 mg of calcium) are all great ways to get your daily intake of calcium without the help of cow’s milk and dairy products.

Also Read : The Verdict Is In for the Cow’s Milk vs. Goat’s Milk Debate

Sources for Today’s Article:
Mateljan, G., The World’s Healthiest Foods: Essential Guide for the healthiest way of eating (Seattle: George Mateljan Foundation, 2007), 520, 738.
Michaelsson, K., et al., “Milk intake and risk of mortality and fractures in women and men: cohort studies,” BMJ 2014; 349: g6015, doi: 10.1136/bmj.g6015.
Crew, B., “Study suggests milk doesn’t strengthen your bones – it ages you instead,” Science Alert web site, October 30, 2014; http://www.sciencealert.com/study-suggests-milk-doesnt-strengthen-your-bones-it-ages-you-instead.




WANT MORE HEALTH NEWS & UPDATES?
Sign up for the latest health news, tips and special product offers with our daily Free e-Letters, the Doctors Health Press e-Bulletin and the Health eTalk with the Bel Marra Doctors.

Opt-in by entering your e-mail address below and clicking submit. Your e-mail will never be shared, sold or rented to anyone for promotional or advertising purposes, and you can unsubscribe easily at any time.

Yes, I’m opting in for the FREE Doctors Health Press e-Bulletin and
Health eTalk with the Bel Marra Doctors:

Jon Yaneff, CNP

About the Author, Browse Jon's Articles

Jon Yaneff is a holistic nutritionist and health researcher with a background in journalism. After years of a hectic on-the-go, fast food-oriented lifestyle as a sports reporter, Jon knew his life needed a change. He began interviewing influential people in the health and wellness industry and incorporating beneficial health and wellness information into his own life. Jon’s passion for his health led him to the certified nutritional practitioner (CNP) program at the Institute of Holistic Nutrition. He graduated with first... Read Full Bio »